QUOTE (Chatelier @ Feb 22 2009, 12:15 PM)

Thanks Emilio, I will try it in French, as I have read the German I will know the story line and it will b e a good excersise for my French. I agree with you about Tracy Chevalier. Do you know "Mills and Boon" novels. I always think she writes not much better than those authors and still is quite famous.
I agree. I even think a few of Harlequin's writers (your now centenary Mills and Boon!) display a better style than Tracy Chevalier! She became known for "The Girl with the Pearl Earring", a totally fictitious novel about a never existed maid of famous painter Johannes Vermeer from Delft. She made many Dutchmen angry by her "inventions". The same goes for the movie of the same name, in which canals of Venice are shown instead of the canals of Delft!!! (on short exception).
My biggest disappointment with her was reading "The Lady and the Unicorn", in connection with the marvelous set of late medieval Brussels tapestries in the Musée du Moyen Age (Maison Cluny) in Paris. Her research had been so poor ( non existent in fact) that she made Brussels a French speaking city while it was 100% Dutch speaking (= Flemish) at that time. She gave the weavers French names instead of Flemish ones, let them import their English wool from Ostend instead of from Antwerp and, last but not least, allowed soldiers of the French King to come to Brussels to fetch the tapestries! This would of course be totally impossible: imagine a foreign army entering another country without authorization of the local monarch! I could go on forever with all her serious mistakes, in particular the patronising of the Parisian painter towards the Brussels people which, at that time, was wealthier and more opulent than the Parisians.
The problem is that most people don't know anything about these subjects and so don't realise how crappy the work is!